Joseph Christopher Rosenbaum Jr., 98, entered into rest on Wednesday June 8, 2022. So first he lit a fire. We contacted the Arizona Department of Corrections, and they confirmed that the middle name and date of birth for the Arizona offender is the same as those of the Joseph Rosenbaum with the Kenosha address in Wisconsin court records. WiCourts.gov. It was created to raise money for Huber's funeral costs and other expenses incurred by his loss. He was met at the gates of heaven by his Wife, Clara Ann Vanover Rosenbaum; Parents, Joseph Christopher Rosenbaum, Sr. and Dorothy Haun Rosenbaum; Son in law, Bobby Bossmeyer. We also found shell casings Kenosha police missed at the first Rittenhouse shooting scene. The 29-year-old father of six was shot several times by a Wisconsin cop. He spent a lot of time at the local skate park and also struggled with bipolar disorder. On November 19, a jury acquitted him on all charges. It gives his nickname as JoJo. The two people killed were identified as 36-year-old Joseph Rosenbaum, of Kenosha, and 26-year-old Anthony Huber, of Silver Lake, Wisconsin. We asked the Wisconsin Department of Corrections if they had a Joseph Rosenbaum on the registry before and they said yes and they were notified hes now deceased. As a child he had no relationship with his father, was molested by his stepfather, and was sent to a group home at age 13 when his mother went to prison. Died: Friday, September 13th, 2019 He was killed. "I don't think that any of us who were directly involved in what happened last year on the 25th are really that surprised. It's never been about politics. Why are the Kenosha protests happening? One. Who Where Year of death State Range Receive obituaries Charles E. Stevens Adams, Wisconsin February 13, 2023 (81 years old) View obituary Beatrice Conners The victims of August 25 shooting at the Kenosha, Wisconsin protests were named as Anthony Huber and Joseph Rosenbaum. To understand what happened what happened in Kenosha on August 25, 2020, we must look at the life of Joseph Rosenbaum in the tension between these two meanings. Rosenbaum, meanwhile, was unarmed and carried a plastic bag containing a toothbrush, toothpaste, socks, deodorant and some papers. To be clear, we dont think the criminal history of everyone shot and killed is relevant in crime stories. He lived in Arizona, where he went to high school and a community college, before moving to Wisconsin in 2020, per news reports and his Facebook page.. No Joseph Rosenbaum is found on the Wisconsin sex offender registry right now, but he may have been removed because hes deceased. Prosecutors moved for the case to be dismissed after a hearing, and it was. Fred was born September 27, 1935, in Black River Falls, WI, the 3rd of 8 children to Herman & Birdie (Spunaugle) Rosenbaum. ", Asked about the call for protests following today's verdict, Hancock said, "The family calls for calm. We know that this system is a failure," she said. Published by Legacy. He died just days after his birthday, according to an obituary. Gaige Paul Grosskreutz has a forfeiture case for not showing obedience to officers, as well as one for loud noises. Rittenhouse fell to the ground and shot and missed a man. Hes in the red shirt. Degree as a journeyman plumber in Local 434 where he spent his next 20 years. Others were also chasing Rittenhouse at the time, video shows. Rosenbaum was a registered sex offender. mark pignotti $50 15 mos Peter Lander $50 15 mos Anonymous $40 15 mos David Wylie $20 24 mos Anonymous $25 26 mos See all See top Adriana Garcia is organizing this fundraiser on behalf of Clint Eubank. He was convicted of two amended counts as part of a plea deal. Rosenbaum threw a plastic bag at Rittenshouse and tried to grab the rifle. 2 Rosenbaum left behind his now 3-year-old daughter who lives in Waco Credit: Facebook/Joseph Rosenbaum Who was Joseph D. Rosenbaum? Rosenbaum was identified as a registered sex offender, convicted in Arizona for "sexual conduct with a minor" , according to Wisconsin sex offender . Grosskreutzs arrest history from the state Department of Justice is lengthy. Jackson said that a garbage can was thrown after Rittenhouse was upset that Black Lives Matter protesters were lighting a fire. Here's. Obituaries can vary in the amount of information they contain, but many of them are genealogical goldmines, including information such as: names, dates, place of birth and death, marriage information, and family . He is seeking privacy after all of the attention from the past year, his attorney said, according to WTMJ-TV. Rosenbaum was killed and Grosskreutz was injured in the August 2020 shooting. But here we are, in a pathetic nation, unable to take the most basic care of our citizens, hanging between the urge to feel contempt and scorn for our failed institutions and the widespread ignorance and irrationality of our citizenry (both Red Tribe and Blue Tribe), and the urge to feel sympathy for so many suffering people even, if our hearts are strong enough, those guilty of horrific crimes. Lunch will be served back at the Rosenbaum Family Farm. Within seconds of the tussle, Rittenhouse fired a single fatal shot into Huber, who can be seen staggering away, then collapsing onto the ground, in video footage of the incident. Email us at exclusive@the-sun.com or call 212 416 4552. Why Weve Decided to Tell You the Criminal Records of the Men Shot in Kenosha. Afraid, Rittenhouse took off running and Rosenbaum gave chase. When it ended, Anthony Huber and Joseph Rosenbaum were dead, and Gaige Grosskreutz had been shot and injured. According to an eyewitness he said that he would kill [you] motherfuckers, motherfucking niggers and cut [your] hearts out.. The Wisconsin legislature should never have drafted a law allowing 17-year-olds to carry rifles on city streets. The two men killed were Joseph Rosenbaum, 36, of Kenosha, and Anthony. He made lifetime friends wherever he went and had many humorous stories of on-the-job hijinks. "Those are his plans moving forward. Many Godds, Many Relationships, Always Learning. A small memorial decorates a lamp post on September 1, 2020 near where Joseph Rosenbaum and Anthony Huber were shot and killed in Kenosha, Wisconsin. Goodnight moon. I have no answer. After Rittenhouse shot and killed Joseph Rosenbaum, he ran from the scene down Sheridan Road. Why We've Decided to Tell You the Criminal Records of the Men Gaige Grosskreutz, Joseph Rosenbaum & Anthony Huber Criminal Records Explored, New Kyle Rittenhouse Witness Could Clear Him of Murder, Jim Piwowarczyk of Wisconsin Right Now Wins Excellence in Journalism Award, Republican Budget Chiefs: Brewers Stadium Deal Must Make Sense For Taxpayers, Biden Takes Fire After Vowing to Ban Assault Weapons, FBI Now Confirms COVID-19 Likely Came From Wuhan Lab, Greg Borowski, Do the Right Thing & Delete the Disgraceful Michael Dorow Story, Elijah D. Combs, Man Accused of Murdering Milwaukee Common Council Presidents Niece is Dead, Janet Protasiewicz Ducking First Supreme Court Debate, to Be Replaced by Chair, Kendrew Wilson, Accused of Raping Waukesha Business Owner, Was Out on Bail, Wisconsin Republicans Push Mandatory Minimum for Felons With Guns, Accused Killer Given Weak Sentence by Janet Protasiewicz Stomped & Strangled Milwaukee Woman, Milwaukee Police Breaking News Feb 28, 2023, National Debt Interest Payments Will Exceed Defense Spending This Decade, CBO Says, Supreme Court Justices Raise Concerns About Bidens Ability to Forgive Student Debt, Wisconsin Supreme Court Spending Continues, Pro-Kelly Group Places First Ad, Janet Protasiewicz Gave Weak Sentence to Man Accused of Murdering Milwaukee Common Council Presidents Niece, Wisconsin DPI Celebrates Public School Week With Op-ed Defining Public Schools, Op-Ed: As Trump Attacks, DeSantis Touts Courage to Buck Lockdowners in New Book, Report: U.S. Energy Department Says COVID-19 Likely Came From Chinese Lab, Fond du Lac Judge Orders Kauls Crime Lab to Test Sample After Delay in Drunk Driving Homicide Case, Milwaukee Public Museum Admits It Cant Move Murals; Exhibit Designer Wants Historic Artworks Preserved, BLM Disrupts Candy Cane Lane in West Allis [VIDEO], Christmas Memorial For Beloved Milwaukee Officer Desecrated With BLM Flag, UW-Madison Police Chief Bans Thin Blue Line, Khalil Coleman: A Milwaukee Protest Leaders Chicago Gangland Ties, Gaige Grosskreutz: Arrested For Prowling Prior to Kenosha Shooting, State Rep. David Bowen: The Making of a Lie, Wauwatosa Police Chief Asked Legislature to Act on State Rep; They Didnt Even Respond, State Senators Call for Investigation Into Green Bay Election, Robin Vos Calls Bowens Actions Abhorrent; Assembly To Discuss Discipline, Khalil Coleman Arrest: Milwaukee Peoples Revolution Leader, Arrested for Robbery in Kentucky, Inside The Peoples Revolution: Gang Ties, Felonies, a State Rep & Congressional Staffer, Barretts Fire & Police Commission Nominee Wants to Abolish Police, In Their Own Words: Two Police Officers Describe Peoples Revolution Mob Attack, Milwaukee Aldermen Call $10 Million COPS Grant Rejection a Sign of Hope, EXCLUSIVE: Waukesha County Sheriff Severson on Joseph Mensah Hiring Decision, Joseph Rosenbaum: Sex Offender 2002 Arizona Criminal Complaint, Exclusive: Tim Michels $17 Million Connecticut Home, New York City Penthouse Raise Residency Questions He Wont Answer, Milwaukee Elections Head Misplaced Crucial Voting Flash Drive [EXCLUSIVE], Tony Evers Killers & Rapists: Nearly 1,000 Freed Criminals Include Wisconsins Most Heinous [WRN EXCLUSIVE], FREED: Biker Raped & Cut the Throat of Green Bay Woman, Tossing Her in Manure Pit | Tony Evers Killers & Rapists #1, Milwaukee Police Body Cam Videos Show Keishon Thomas Hiding, Ingesting Drugs, Damar Hamlin Video: Condition Critical After CPR Attempted, FREED: Carl Beletsky Killed, Decapitated Wife in Oconomowoc; Burned Head in Wood Stove | Tony Evers Killers & Rapists #8, Trumps Thrashing of Kleefisch & Her Family Was Disgusting, Darreon Parker-Bell: Suspect in Milwaukee Police District 5 Shooting, WRN EXCLUSIVE: Violent Rapist Released by Evers Appointee in June, Now Charged with Strangulation, False Imprisonment, Wisconsin Assembly Candidate Adam Steen Secretly Recorded Calls With Top Republicans, Called Voters Stupid, Tim Michels Tied to Groups That Pushed Aggressively for Gas Tax Increases, Kenosha Police Shooting: Imperative We Wait For The Facts. He also had a forfeiture case for possessing drug paraphernalia. Hubers shooting occurred seconds after another unidentified man jumped at and over Rittenhouse, who fired at him, but missed, the complaint says. Things have gone off the rails in relation to who Kyle is and why he was down here. Wisconsin obituaries and death notices, 1989 to 2023. Rosenbaum left behind his now 3-year-old daughter who. Joseph Rosenbaum, 36, of Kenosha. "He died last night in the protest for Jacob Blake. Gaige Grosskreutz was shot and injured by Kyle Rittenhouse. Medical Examiner: Joseph Rosenbaum May Have Fallen Toward Kyle Rittenhouse Because He'd Been Shot, Not Because He Lunged Aaron Keller Nov 9th, 2021, 1:25 pm Kyle Rittenhouse appears in a Kenosha County, Wisconsin courtroom on Mon., Nov. 8, 2021, during his intentional homicide trial. He was 76. He had both an open domestic violence case and a bail jumping case against him when he died, and his fiance had taken out a no-contact order against him after he (allegedly) attacked her. "He wasn't down there as a rioter or a looter," Rosenbaum's fiance told the Post in reference to August 25. He was born September 13, 1931 to Frank Eugene and Mary . Sean Krajacic-Pool/Getty Images Another militia group called the boogaloo also attended the demonstrations in Kenosha. "He died last night in the protest for Jacob Blake. And the Facebook page of the Joseph Rosenbaum who was shot by Rittenhouse indicates hes engaged to Kariann, confirming the CCAP entries. Joseph Frank Rosenbaum, 71, died Friday, Sept. 13, 2019 at Mayo Clinic Health System - Eau Claire as a result of a blood clotting disorder. Huber had turned 26 just four days earlier, according to an obituary. He had moved to Kenosha in the year before the shooting. State prosecutors have charged 17-year-old Kyle Rittenhouse of Antioch, Illinois, with murder in the deaths of Huber and Joseph Rosenbaum. JOSEPH D. Rosenbaum was shot in the head on August 25, 2020, during the heated Black Lives Matter demonstrations in Kenosha, Wisconsin. Asked if he stood by his past comments equating Rittenhouse to a white supremacist, Biden didnt directly answer. The complaint says that Rosenbaum did initially try to engage the defendant. Rosenbaum also had open misdemeanor cases for battery (domestic abuse) and disorderly conduct (domestic abuse). Kenosha, WI 53144. Could the truth be complicated? KENOSHA, WI Joseph Rosenbaum, who died after being allegedly shot by Kyle Rittenhouse, 17, on Aug. 25, appears to have been charged by an Arizona grand jury with 11 counts of child molestation and inappropriate sexual activity around children, including sodomy.. Grosskreutz was armed with a pistol that night. Read all of our Rittenhouse exclusives here. Heres a video that shows Rosenbaum acting aggressively shortly before the shooting. He had bipolar disorder. He was caught on camera acting aggressively that evening, setting fires, arming himself with a chain, and screaming shoot me, nigger! at armed citizens. Many hours were spent cutting trees, cleaning cemetery, and providing and running high-lift equipment for those repairing the steeple. McGinnis demonstrated by extending both of his hands in a quick grabbing motion and did that as a visual on how Rosenbaum tried to reach for the defendants gunMcGinnis said that he definitely made a motion that he was trying to grab the barrel of the gun. Anthony Huber, 26, who lived in Kenosha County. The word pathetic has two very different senses. Wisconsin authorities have identified the two men who were allegedly shot dead by a 17-year-old earlier this week during a protest in Kenosha over the shooting of Jacob Blake by police. Rittenhouse was carrying a Smith & Wesson AR-15 style .223 rifle. Mark Richards, Kyle Rittenhouse's defense attorney, said his client is eager to get on with his life and is feeling a great sense of relief following his acquittal on all five counts against him today. Kariann Swart, the late Joseph Rosenbaum's fiance, testified during Kyle Rittenhouse's trial on Nov. 5 in Kenosha, Wis. Rosenbaum was raised in Texas and Arizona, according to The Washington Post. Joseph Rosenbaum, 36, and Anthony Huber, 26, were both killed by . He was also accused of prowling by West Allis police. For other inquiries, Contact Us. Swart had pressed charges against Rosenbaum in July 2020 after a fight in which he assaulted her, the paper reported. He was shot in. Richards said that he had confidence in his self-defense case and believed that Schroeder had created an environment where his client could receive justice. BOLCKOW, Mo. On that day, Rosenbaum had just been discharged from a Milwaukee hospital following the second suicide attempt. A third man, Gaige P. Grosskreutz, was also wounded in . But along the way, several protesters who believed Rittenhouse was an active shooter began chasing after him. To plant a beautiful memorial tree in memory of Anthony Michael Huber, please visit our tree store. Wisconsin Right Now is a Wisconsin-focused news platform with breaking news & some opinion. Gaige Grosskreutz was shot and injured by Kyle Rittenhouse. More than a year later, a jury found him not guilty on five charges, including first-degree intentional homicide, in a case that has captivated, and divided, a nation. People on social media are alleging that Grosskreutz is a Wisconsin felon. Violent unrest has been raging in Kenosha, Wisconsin following the shooting of unarmed Jacob Blake by . Grosskreutz became a paramedic after high school, but the profession left him burned out, according to the Post. The 12 jurors found him not guilty for the deaths of Joseph Rosenbaum, 36, and Anthony Huber, 26, and wounding Gaige Grosskreutz, now 27, using an AR-15-type rifle during protests on August 25,. Inside sinister rise of pink cocaine sweeping UK nightclubs as warring cartels battle to control 'Coca Cola of drugs', How 'deluded' Putin thought Ukraine invasion would break up Nato & have West bowing down to Russia, leaked docs show, Leicester 'explosion': Listen to massive 'sonic' boom that shook homes and rattled windows, 'Bubbly' nightclub worker, 31, killed after her Audi crashed into a bridge on her way home from work. Last week, witnesses testified that the first man to be shot, Rosenbaum, 36, was "hyperaggressive" and "acting belligerently" that night and threatened to kill Rittenhouse at one point. kill [you] motherfuckers, motherfucking niggers and cut [your] hearts out., a former employee of an Indian-American owned car lot, to protect what was left of that business from rioters. He is said to have spent more than a decade in prison in Arizona after being convicted of sexual conduct with a minor. Who was Joseph D. Rosenbaum and how did he die in the Kenosha protests? ", As for the Rittenhouse family, Hancock said, "They are doing well right now. Or it may refer to that which is so inadequate that it arouses contempt or scorn. The complaint does not explain what authorities believe instigated that first argument. "So I think it's a good system. His family laughs about how much he hated life on the dairy farm, but how much he loved it without the cows. What makes their criminal histories relevant for the public to at least consider: The three men who were shot had placed themselves in the midst of a scene of violent rioting that, for days, included lawless anarchy (there were arson fires in the area that night too), and the defendant is on video saying earlier that he was there to prevent damage to people and property. "The Sun", "Sun", "Sun Online" are registered trademarks or trade names of News Group Newspapers Limited. hide caption. He was convicted of a criminal misdemeanor in 2016 for going armed with a firearm while intoxicated. Like us on Facebook at www.facebook.com/TheSunUS and follow us from our main Twitter account at @TheSunUS, News Group Newspapers Limited in England No. Motorcycles, vintage cars and tractors welcome. Jacob Blake should not have (allegedly) committed sexual assault. On Memo line please write: Food Challenge. McGinnis stated that the defendant pulled it away and then raised it., But, but, but he was just apeaceful protestor holding a cell phone pic.twitter.com/EEp45iDOqj, James Woods (@RealJamesWoods) August 26, 2020. Given this, it is truly amazing that some on what passes for a left in the US are trying to claim him as a heroic protester against racism. https://wcca.wicourts.gov/caseDetail.html?caseNo=2020CM000836&countyNo=30&index=0&mode=details, https://wcca.wicourts.gov/caseDetail.html?caseNo=2020CM000903&countyNo=30&index=0&mode=details, https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2020/10/03/kenosha-shooting-victims/, https://www.wisconsinrightnow.com/2021/03/11/joseph-rosenbaum-sex-offender/, https://www.wisconsinrightnow.com/2021/03/12/kenosha-shooting/, https://www.kenoshanews.com/did-car-source-ask-for-armed-help-during-kenosha-unrest-witness-testimony-differs/article_d0d31293-6736-53f4-9dcc-f448f37b2952.html, https://hotair.com/john-s-2/2021/11/09/things-joseph-rosenbaum-allegedly-said-and-did-on-the-night-he-was-shot-n428183. It is unclear if Rittenhouse is a member of the Kenosha Guard Militia. Even as I think that Rittenhouse was legally justified to shoot him in self-defense, when I think of that bag the hospital gave him as the last thing he ever owned, I find myself moved to pathos. Kelley testified Tuesday that Huber died from a single gunshot wound to his chest that caused blood loss and extensive trauma to his heart and lungs. During the trial, Schroeder, who has a reputation as a tough jurist, had some heated exchanges with prosecutor Thomas Binger for his line of questioning as Rittenhouse testified. A jury on Friday found Kyle Rittenhouse not guilty on all charges related to his shooting of three men on Aug. 25, 2020. The conditions of bond read: Not to Possess or Consume Alcohol. The Wisconsin and Arizona initial offense dates are also the same. On Friday, a Kenosha, Wisconsin jury found Rittenhouse not guilty of killing Rosenbaum, who had been chasing Rittenhouse before the teenager shot in self-defense . He testified on Nov. 8. Montie L. Rosenbaum, 80, Bolckow, died Sunday, January 8, 2012 at a local health care facility. (Richie) McGinnis (an eyewitness) stated that as the defendant was walking Rosenbaum was trying to get closer to the defendant. The GoFundMe page is no longer accepting donations but says they received a total of $21,988. A Charge Dismissed but Read In Modifier: 968.075(1)(a) Domestic Abuse Modifier: 939.63(1)(a) Use of a Dangerous Weapon, 5 947.01(1) Disorderly Conduct Misd. People have come to our command posts We have pallets of water and Gatorade.". B Charge Dismissed but Read In Modifier: 968.075(1)(a) Domestic Abuse Modifier: 939.63(1)(a) Use of a Dangerous Weapon, 6 947.01(1) Disorderly Conduct Misd. [Anthony] Huber told his brother that if he didnt start cleaning a room in his house he was going to gut him like a pig, Rittenhouses lawyer Corey Chirafisi said in court adding, according to The New York Post that Huber did this while holding a 6-inch butchers knife to the brothers stomach., Huber grabbed his brother by the neck, dug his nails in and choked him for approximately ten seconds, Chirafisi said. Motorcycles, vintage cars and tractors welcome. "R.I.P TO BOTH," she wrote in reference to Huber. He allegedly fled Wisconsin for his home state following the shooting. He gave a West Allis address. A native of Texas, Joseph was 36 years old and was 5 feet and 3 inches in height. Minors can also . "Today we grieve for the families of those slain by Kyle Rittenhouse," Motley and Schwab said in a statement. Teenager shot Joseph Rosenbaum four times at close range including once in the back during Kenosha protest Maya Yang Tue 9 Nov 2021 13.57 EST Last modified on Wed 17 Nov 2021 18.22 EST But it is not the complete truth. Rittenhouse was arrested by police in August 2020 and charged with first-degree murder for shooting two people. You can read the lawyers statement here. He was there that night to help out with medical care. News articles say Joseph Jojo Rosenbaum was the father of a 2-year-old girl. He graduated from St. Joseph Catholic Grade School and BRF High School, Class of 1967. Joe was born Feb. 18, 1948, the 7th of 8 children, to the late Herman and Birdie (Spunaugle) Rosenbaum. Heres why. People are spreading the criminal record of another Kyle Rittenhouse around the Internet, but that man is much older and isnt him. His mother was sent to prison when he was 13 and Rosenbaum began using heroin and methamphetamine at a group home where he was sent, the Post reported. Grosskreutz was one of three people that Kyle Rittenhouse, then 18 and an Antioch resident, shot during the August 2020 protests, which were sparked after a Kenosha police officer shot Jacob Blake multiple times. DONATIONS for Joseph Rosenbaum $26,549 raised The organizer has currently disabled new donations to this fundraiser. No Joseph Rosenbaum is found on the Wisconsin sex offender registry right now, but he may have been removed because he's deceased. Turns out the man Kyle Rittenhouse shot and killed last night in #Kenosha was Joseph D Rosenbaum, a convicted sex offender of sexual conduct with a minor, Here is video I shot of him begging to be shot in front of a gas station minutes before his death pic.twitter.com/tUfUGWX3io, Drew Hernandez (@DrewHLive) August 27, 2020. Sensitive readers should be advised. Video journalist Richie McGinniss, who was with shooting victim Joseph Rosenbaum as he was dying, told HuffPost about the tragedy that unfolded that night. Court documents showed that Rosenbaum was accused of sexually abusing five pre-teen boys in 2002, was indicted on 11 counts of child molestation, and eventually pleaded guilty to two amended counts of sexual conduct with a minor. Rittenhouse mat a tiros a Joseph Rosenbaum y Anthony Huber e hiri a Gaige Grosskreutz mientras aparentemente custodiaba un estacionamiento de autos usados con un rifle estilo AR-15 en el . Wisconsins largest newspaper, The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, argued that readers shouldnt get to know the shot mens criminal records. Joseph Rosenbaum has a long and troubled past with a felony . He had spent most of his adult life in prison for sexual conduct with children when he was 18 and struggled . Note: This post discusses violence and sexual abuse, and for the sake of accuracy quotes unexpurgated the use of a vile racial slur and other curse words. Hancock also said he believed that "the jury was thoughtful and they understood the gravity of this decision. The witnesses believed this ignited the argument between Rittenhouse and the first victim. "May you forever be with the angels and rest easy bro. Inside sick Honeytrap plot that left man dead after women seduced and drugged him to steal his Rolex watches, Man had sex with his wife on bollard after fuming neighbour placed it in cul-de-sac in protest during parking row, Man, 42, killed after being hit by digger as driver arrested for gross negligence manslaughter, Rittenhouse was later charged with five felony counts, Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO), Jacob Blake was shot at by Wisconsin policeapproximately seven times and is currently paralyzed from the waist down, On Sunday evening,shocking footageemerged showingBlake being gunned down bypolice, His family was sitting in the car as they watched police shoot him in the back, Blake was reportedly gearing up to celebrate his son's eighth birthday.